Beyond the Basics

Assessing Private Credit BDCs

Jack Snyder
My name is Jack Snyder. I’m the head of U.S. Wealth at Antares Capital. In this month's Antares Beyond the Basics, we'll be discussing what advisors and investors should be evaluating as they assess their current private credit allocations and potential future investments in the space. Private credit has become a replacement to many top core fixed income categories, and we feel that trend will continue. It's now more important than ever to continue to evaluate managers and the structures in which they're providing their solutions. At Antares, we’ll continue to be a resource for you in the space as you navigate the current private credit markets.

Steve Rubinstein
So, we need to do a little more research than just looking at the headline yield. Comparing BDCs just by their headline distribution yield is the equivalent of judging a book by its cover. Advisors need to also consider the change in NAV. What's the reason for any increases or decreases? And then ultimately, how do those decreases impact the total return?

Software is topical now, but it's not too dissimilar from recent conversations we've been having with financial advisors about redemptions, PIK interest, and, in the past, rising interest rates. It's critical that financial advisors understand the strategy of the credit manager and that the assets in the underlying portfolio match that strategy.

Some of the most common questions that we get from financial advisors include the following. You can't just rely on the average position size within the BDC, but what are the concentrations within the top 10 or top 25 positions? PIK interest. What percent of the net investment income is from PIK interest? Industry diversification. Does the manager have sound diversification by industry in order to build an all-weather portfolio? Another common question that we get is the percent of BSL assets in the portfolio, also referred to as level two assets. These BDCs are designed to carry mostly private credit assets, and the advisor should make sure they understand how much private credit assets are included versus liquid credit. And finally, arguably the most important, is percent of non-accrual assets, so what percent of the portfolio is not paying current interest at the borrower level.

So, let's first talk about what is PIK income, “payment in kind”. We're first lien cash flow lenders. The expectation should be that all of the interest income received is paid in cash. You've heard us talk before about good PIK and bad PIK. Let's start with good PIK, also referred to as PIK at origination. This is when we offer our most creditworthy borrowers an opportunity to pick a portion of their cash interest payment for a limited period of time. Not necessarily a sign of stress, but it's something that is relevant in our market today. On the other hand, bad PIK, which could be PIK at amendment, is when the borrower may be underperforming, and the private credit manager and the private equity sponsor worked together to assist in the liquidity of the borrower, where the manager may defer a portion of the interest in the form of PIK, and the private equity sponsor would put in incremental capital to assist in the liquidity by putting in additional equity. The financial advisor should ask how much of the quarterly interest income is paid in cash versus PIK. They should ask how that percentage has increased over time. And third, they should ask how much of the PIK percentage is from bad PIK or assets that are currently valued at less than $0.90. An additional contributor of PIK interest may be from investments made on a junior capital basis. That could be second lien, mezz, or preferred equity. Again, not necessarily a bad investment for the manager or for the investor. It's important to know that the manager is investing in assets consistent with their stated strategy.

Again, this is where research is important. High PIK may not directly mean credit stress, but it's a trigger for a financial advisor to ask the question. BDC non-accrual levels range anywhere between zero to the mid-single digits, and on average we're right around 1.5%. So, it's important to understand if the PIK interest is generated from good assets at origination or more stressed assets which could lead to higher non-accrual levels at a future time period.

Does the credit manager have their own in-house restructuring expertise? Do they have experience managing those types of situations? Have they made the investment in a scaled team where they can actually lead and drive the negotiations? Private credit workouts are unique in that there's multiple constituents, and the in-house expertise is critical to manage those. You need to know how to work with the private equity sponsor and encourage them to remain active and involved throughout the restructure process. You need to have the wherewithal to manage other lenders in the first lien bank group, as well as manage the interests of the management team, who is still responsible for running the business.

After we've established the size of the workout capabilities within the private credit manager, it's a good idea to ask for specific examples of when they successfully maximize capital preservation throughout the workout process, and maybe for an example or two when the restructure didn't go as well and there were some lessons learned.

This starts with the originations capabilities. Again, has the private credit manager made the investment in a scaled originations team in order to start the top of the funnel and see as many quality opportunities as possible. This really drives better credit decisions to be able to select for the best available opportunities. The risk here is that if they don't see sufficient private credit opportunities, the manager may stretch for less creditworthy borrowers and go outside of their stated strategy. This could be particularly the case in times when the supply/demand imbalance is not in favor of the private credit manager, and they stretch for more risk, which could be more yield. Ensuring historical deployment, consistent with the stated strategy, is critical for dependable long term returns. Additionally, we need to identify how much level two or BSL assets the private credit manager has invested in their BDC. If they're not able to identify sufficient private credit opportunities, it may lead to increased level two or BSL investments. Those assets carry a tighter spread and are subject to daily volatility, which could have more impact on the net asset value. Finally, level two assets could be purchased more efficiently in a different vehicle outside of a BDC, which is primarily designed to hold private credit assets. The financial advisor should ask what is the current BSL allocation? How did it get to that level and what are the plans for future management of that BSL allocation?

All of these questions from the financial advisor are important, so they can fully understand what investment they're making, who is the manager, and what assets are they investing in. It's important to go beyond the headline distribution yield and really dig into the manager’s stated strategy to ensure that the investments in the BDC today and tomorrow will remain consistent with that strategy.

At Antares, our goal is the same today as it has been for the last 30 years. Build diversified and defensively constructed portfolios that are designed to build current and consistent income for our investors.

Jack Snyder
As always, our goal is to be a resource for you as you navigate the current private credit markets. Thanks for joining us.

In our latest Beyond the Basics episode, Steve Rubinstein explains what advisors should consider when evaluating private credit managers, their strategies, and underlying portfolios.

Key Takeaways

Look beyond distribution rates

Distribution yield alone doesn’t tell the full story. Consider changes in NAV and their impact on total return when comparing BDCs.


Understand what’s driving PIK income

Higher PIK income isn’t necessarily a sign of credit stress, but advisors should understand how much income is paid in cash versus PIK – and what is driving that PIK.


Dig into the underlying portfolio

Look at concentration, industry diversification, non-accruals and the mix of private versus broadly syndicated loan assets. Check whether those investments align with the manager’s stated strategy.


Evaluate the manager’s capabilities

Originations scale, selectivity, and in-house restructuring expertise can provide important context for how a manager constructs portfolios and navigates challenging credits.


Go deeper on these themes in Steve Rubinstein’s latest article, Private Credit: Why the Differences Matter Now, and visit our Elements of Private Credit learning hub for additional resources.