Understand what you own, why you own it, and what drives performance.
Private credit continues to grow, and the conversations I have with financial advisors continue to evolve. Advisors are more inquisitive and ask excellent questions about total returns, asset quality, and fund liquidity. Increasingly, these discussions go beyond fund performance and into the manager’s strategy, experience, and ability to manage the investment.
With more managers, strategies, and structures to choose from, deeper diligence matters. Over the past year conversations have started with redemptions, software and AI risk, or signs of credit stress. These are valid concerns. The question that remains is what these concerns mean for the particular fund a client owns.
In our July commentary, What the Headlines Miss, we considered those concerns alongside continued institutional demand and modestly improving economics for new assets. We also emphasized underwriting discipline, selective origination, and the ability to manage underperforming credits.
When evaluating a business development company, or BDC, I would start with two areas.
01
Understand what drives performance
Distribution rate is a reasonable place to begin, but it is not enough to assess performance. Advisors also need to consider changes in net asset value, or NAV, and total return. What has the investor earned, and what drives that result?
A decline in NAV may reflect market-driven valuation changes for performing borrowers, deterioration in borrower performance, or both. Investors should understand the reason for the change before reaching a conclusion about the portfolio.
For software borrowers, for example, I would ask how the underwriting thesis is holding up and what the current data shows about customer retention, pricing, margins and volume.
It is also important to look beneath the surface of non-accruals for other indicators of credit stress that may lead to future defaults such as marks below 80 that are not already on non-accrual and/or high levels of Payment-in-kind, or PIK income. PIK is interest income that is capitalized rather than currently paid in cash. PIK structured at origination may give a creditworthy borrower temporary flexibility. PIK introduced through an amendment when a borrower is underperforming may signal potential stress and a need for liquidity support.
Ask how much interest income is paid in cash versus PIK, how that mix has changed and how the PIK percentage compares with other BDCs pursuing similar strategies. Use consistent definitions and reporting periods. A higher percentage should prompt further questions, not an automatic conclusion.
At your next review, ask the manager to explain the principal drivers of income and NAV changes, with supporting portfolio information.
02
Does the portfolio reflect the manager’s strategy?
Let’s use broadly syndicated loans, or BSLs, as an example. In moderation, these more liquid loans may help a perpetual BDC manage leverage and liquidity. However, they may also introduce greater valuation volatility and lower spreads than comparable privately originated loans.
Ask what role the BSL allocation serves, how it reached the current level and how the manager plans to manage it going forward.
For our strategy, we use BSLs as a backup source of liquidity, with small, diversified positions in borrowers we consider higher quality. Ask what role the BSL allocation serves in the fund you are evaluating. Is it primarily held for liquidity, or does it also include buying and trading discounted loans for potential price gains? How did the allocation reach its current level, and how does the manager plan to manage it going forward?
I would also ask more about the platform and the manager behind the fund. When I think about scale, I am not simply referring to fund size. I want to know about the size and quality of the proprietary origination, underwriting and credit advisory teams and how long they have been working together. Does the manager see enough opportunities to remain selective, build a diversified portfolio, and stay within its stated strategy?
Ask the manager to identify a meaningful change in portfolio composition since your last review and explain how it fits the strategy.
A change does not automatically indicate a problem. It warrants a review of what changed, why, and what it means for the fund.
Keep the assessment going
You are investing in the manager, their strategy, and their history as much as you are investing in the fund. The work does not end at investment. Continue to assess manager and fund performance, and whether the fund still fits your client’s needs.
View our additional resources designed to help advisors bring structure to that work: understand what you own, what drives performance, and what to revisit over time.
Disclosures
Antares Capital Credit Advisers LLC is a registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. This content is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice or an offer to buy or sell any security or fund. 97075824.1
