Exploring Investor Interest in CLO Equity

Seth Painter
The biggest trend has just been around the growth of the market. The market continues to grow alongside the rapid growth of the loan market. CLOs are the largest buyers of corporate loans at around 60% of the buyer base. There's more than $1 trillion of CLOs outstanding today. That's more than double the size of the market less than five years ago, and this year is trending to be potentially the highest year issuance year on record. Today, issuance is around $300 billion. The highest issuance year ever was in 2021 at $425 billion. So, we're right on pace. The question is what's really caused the market to be so active, and I think it's largely driven by spreads. The spreads have tightened on the CLO debt tranches, which has helped improve the arbitrage and improve the expected returns to the equity investors. There's been a lot of refinancing activity. The equity can lock in long-term financing at a very attractive cost of capital. So, it's just been a really good time to issue, and you're seeing that in the numbers and you're seeing that in the forward pipeline.

Antares has been active in this market for several years. We've raised 18 CLOs to date across private credit and BSL and breaking it down just a little bit further, we've done 15 private credit CLOs for about $14.3 billion. In three BSL CLOs for approximately $1.4 billion. So today we have about $15.7 billion in CLOs outstanding, and we expect to continue to be a prolific issuer in this market. For us, for the types of loan portfolios and the funds that we construct and the funds that we manage, we think the CLO structure is just a superior structure to alternative funding options.

Well investors have been active in BSL equity for several years, but there's never been much of an opportunity to invest in private credit CLO equity and I think that's changing. We think the expansion of private credit will continue to occur, which will further segment the investor base. Investors will have varying yield demands. Investors who are looking for private equity like returns can potentially find that in private credit, with the appropriate leverage and the appropriate structure in place. So, the unique opportunity we see available in the market is for those investors who are seeking higher risk adjusted returns, comfortable with leverage, and have the appropriate capital to commit to a potential long-term investment. They may have to get comfortable with giving up some liquidity, but there are two important items as it relates to liquidity. We think investors are paid a healthy premium for that illiquidity and CLOs provide quarterly distributions to the equity investors, so there's current income. And then I'd say we think investors are interested for the same reason we like equity in this market. CLOs generally offer the lowest cost of capital for this asset class. Equity investors get the benefit of long-term financing, so very limited asset and liability mismatch risk. And the third is it's generally non-market-to-market financing, so there's no margin call risk. So, we think the structure works well and so what I think will be interesting for investors is being able to partner with managers who can offer both BSL and private credit equity.

Well, there are a number of things investors should consider, but I think the two most obvious are the viability of the manager and their track record of producing strong returns. But I'll add a third. I think investors should also be thinking about what is differentiating about the manager. So, let's just quickly step through these. The first I said is the viability. We think this is critical. Investors need to understand and be comfortable that the manager is very committed to their CLO business, very committed to the strategy, and we expect there is going to continue to be consolidation in this market, and making sure that you're investing with someone of scale will be increasingly important. So, understanding the business plan, understanding the ownership structure and the sponsor of the manager is critical. The second item I mentioned was the track record. Obviously, investors should evaluate the manager's track record and how they perform through cycles and specific to private credit, it's important to evaluate the manager's workout capabilities. An experienced workout team can materially impact returns. And the last thing I mentioned was just what's differentiating about the strategy. There's a lot of CLO managers in the market so as an investor I want to know what's differentiated. How can we potentially do something strategic together? How can we create alpha together? How can we partner to find relative value? A partnership that provides exposure to both BSL and private credit could be pretty interesting, pretty differentiating. If you think about the benefits, on the BSL side, you get a couple of things. There's more liquidity in the asset class, so the manager can more actively trade the portfolio, and the BSL market experiences more price volatility so there's an opportunity to buy loans at a deeper discount. So, we think the BSL market may provide more opportunistic windows. On the private credit side there's a yield premium on the assets and the arbitrage to the CLO equity is generally higher. And we think that yield premium is driven by liquidity not more credit risk. So, the equity investor can essentially give up some liquidity in exchange for higher returns, and we think that proposition makes sense for a lot of investors, in particular those investors who are committing their capital to CLO equity funds. They are by definition giving up some liquidity, so we think those LPs would benefit with some exposure to private credit CLO equity.